When it comes to buying insurance, it is good to have options. And knowing who the best life insurance companies are provides you with the insight you need to try and get the best rates.
What To Consider When Comparing Life Insurance Companies
Before diving into specific companies, it’s essential to understand what factors make a life insurance company stand out. Here are key considerations:
- Financial Strength
- Policies Offered
- Underwriting Criteria
- Customer Satisfaction
- Claims Process
Financial Strength: The Foundation of Reliable Insurance
The primary ratings agencies that provide financial strength ratings to different life insurance carriers are A.M. Best Company, Standard and Poor’s, Fitch Ratings, and Moody’s.
These ratings assess an insurer’s ability to meet its financial obligations. Higher ratings suggest financial stability and a lower risk of default, which is critical for long-term policies like life insurance.
For example, an A++ rating from AM Best indicates the highest confidence in the insurer’s ability to pay claims over decades. Companies with the highest ratings are typically those you want to choose.
THE ULTIMATE FREE DOWNLOAD
The Self Banking Blueprint
A Modern Approach To The Infinite Banking Concept
Examples of 2025 Financial Strength Ratings:
- New York Life: Holds the highest ratings from all four major agenciesโA++ (AM Best), Aaa (Moody’s), AAA (Fitch), and AA+ (S&P)
- Protective Life Insurance Company: Rated A+ (AM Best), AA- (S&P and Fitch), and A1 (Moody’s)
- State Farm: Consistently rated A++ by AM Best, indicating superior financial strength
In addition, the Comdex Ranking is also used, which offers a ranking from 1 to 100 based on how each of the different rating agencies scores a life insurance company.
The companies with the highest ratings are typically going to be the insurance companies you want to choose.
Looking for the Right Life Insurance Company?
Compare rates from top-rated carriers on our life insurance quotes page to find policies that match your specific needs and budget.
Customer Satisfaction: What Real Customers Think
According to J.D. Power’s recent U.S. Individual Life Insurance Study:
- State Farm ranked highest for individual life insurance satisfaction with a score of 843, followed by Nationwide (840) and MassMutual (809)
- Digital engagement significantly boosts customer satisfaction, with scores 79 points higher when customers use digital channels
This data shows that companies investing in digital tools for policy management are providing a better customer experience.
Types of Life Insurance Policies
There are different types of life insurance policies. The two main insurance policies offered are term life and permanent life insurance.
Term Life Insurance
Term life is offered in a few different ways, such as convertible term, level term life, annual renewable term, and decreasing term life insurance.
In addition, there are different terms available, such as 5-year, 10, 15, 20, 25, and 30-year terms.
Different term life riders are available such as return of premium, waiver of premium, and terminal illness riders.
The Best Term Life Insurance Companies Are:
Permanent Life Insurance
Permanent life insurance is offered in two different products, whole life vs universal life. Not all life insurance carriers provide each type of permanent insurance coverage.
Whole Life Insurance
Traditional dividend-paying whole life insurance coverage is the more stable insurance product. It offers guaranteed cash value, guaranteed level premiums, and guaranteed death benefit protection.
The Best Dividend Paying Whole Life Insurance Companies Are:
- American United Life
- Guardian
- Lafayette Life
- MassMutual
- New York Life
- Northwestern Mutual
- Ohio National
- Penn Mutual
- Security Mutual
Guaranteed Universal Life
Guaranteed universal life provides a return offered by the insurance company. It is guaranteed based on the criteria that you meet your minimum insurance premium payment. As long as you pay the minimum insurance premiums required, your universal life policy will remain in force.
The Best Guaranteed Universal Life Companies Are:
Indexed Universal Life
Indexed universal life offers indexing tied to the stock market so that your policy can experience potentially higher returns than with whole life.
The IUL index is linked to the stock market but does not directly participate in the stock market.
The IUL insurance policy provides some safety in that there is a floor available which limits potential losses from poor stock market performance.
The Best Indexed Universal Life Companies Are:
Variable Universal Life
Variable life insurance offers many subaccounts, like mutual funds, that allow you to participate in the stock market.
The pros and cons of variable universal life are that you can participate in the gains of the stock market and experience huge growth in your policy’s cash value.
Alternatively, your VUL insurance policy can experience huge losses when the market goes south.
The Best Variable Life Insurance Companies Are:
Looking for the Right Life Insurance Company?
Compare rates from top-rated carriers on our life insurance quotes page to find policies that match your specific needs and budget.
Policy Features That Make a Difference
When comparing policies from different companies, pay attention to these distinguishing features:
Term Life Insurance Features
- State Farm offers customizable term lengths and conversion options to permanent policies
- Banner Life provides competitive rates for higher coverage amounts
Whole Life Insurance Features
- Penn Mutual’s Accumulation Whole Life offers superior early cash value IRR and preferred loan provisions
- New York Life provides dividend-paying policies with guaranteed cash value growth
- Northwestern Mutual offers flexible payment options and strong historical dividend performance
Universal Life Insurance Features
- MassMutual offers flexible premium payments and death benefit adjustments
- Pacific Life provides competitive guaranteed rates
Long-Term Care and Chronic Illness Riders
Additionally, certain companies offer long-term care and chronic illness riders. If you desire certain living benefits attached to your permanent life insurance policy, then knowing which life insurer offers the best living benefit riders is a must.
THE ULTIMATE FREE DOWNLOAD
The Self Banking Blueprint
A Modern Approach To The Infinite Banking Concept
Understanding the Claims Process
The claims process is a critical aspect of life insurance that often gets overlooked until it’s needed. Here’s what you should know:
- Average Claim Approval Time: Most insurers process claims within 30 days, though delays can occur due to incomplete documentation or contestability periods.
- Denial Rates: Approximately 10โ20% of claims are denied, often due to misrepresentation, non-payment of premiums, or exclusions such as suicide clauses.
- Common Issues:
- Misrepresentation of health or lifestyle details
- Lapsed policies due to missed payments
- Exclusions for high-risk activities or pre-existing conditions
Average Premium Costs: What to Expect
Premium costs vary widely based on age, health, and coverage amount:
- A healthy 30-year-old male might pay $25/month for a $500,000 term policy depending on the term length
- Premiums increase significantly with age or health issues; a smoker in their 50s could pay $200/month or more for similar coverage
Shopping around and comparing rates from multiple companies is essential to finding the best value for your specific situation.
Underwriting Criteria
Different insurance companies have different life insurance underwriting criteria. This is important to know because one company may illustrate better than another company, but due to more restrictive medical exam underwriting, as well as how that life insurer views a specific pre-existing medical condition, that company may not offer the best rate class you thought you would qualify for.
As a result, you get a lower rate class than the alternative life insurance company. The lower rate class may affect your policy’s performance.
In hindsight, you realize you should have applied with the other life insurer that had more favorable underwriting criteria for your health profile and any pre-existing conditions and you may have received a better rate class than the company that illustrated better.
This is just one example of why knowing which life insurance company is best (for you) is essential. That is, which company will offer you the best rate class, not necessarily look the best on paper. That way you do not end up paying higher premiums than necessary.
No Exam Options
Finally, another underwriting factor to consider is whether you should take an exam or choose no medical exam life insurance. Many of the top whole life and universal life companies offer programs that allow you to bypass the life insurance blood test altogether.
Matching Companies to Your Specific Needs
Different life insurance companies excel in different areas. Here’s how to match your situation to the right company:
- Young Families: State Farm is ideal for affordable term policies with conversion options
- Retirement Planning: Penn Mutual and Lafayette Life excel in whole life policies with cash value growth
- Estate Planning: Guardian Life offers robust universal life options for wealth transfer
- Business Owners: MassMutual provides buy-sell agreement funding through permanent policies
Current Industry Trends to Watch
Recent trends shaping the life insurance industry include:
- Digital Innovations: Increased use of mobile apps and websites for policy management and claims filing has enhanced customer satisfaction
- Regulatory Changes: Stricter underwriting guidelines and transparency requirements to reduce claim disputes
- New Products: Hybrid policies combining life insurance with long-term care benefits are gaining popularity
Looking for the Right Life Insurance Company?
Compare rates from top-rated carriers on our life insurance quotes page to find policies that match your specific needs and budget.
Comprehensive List of Life Insurance Carriers
- AAA Life Insurance
- AARP Life Review
- AIG American General Life Insurance Company Review
- Allianz Life Review
- American Amicable Review
- AETNA American Continental Insurance Company Review
- American Equity Investment Life Insurance Company Review
- American Home Life Insurance Review
- American National Review
- American United Life Review
- Ameritas Review
- Assurity Life Insurance Review
- AXA Equitable Life Insurance Company Review
- Baltimore Life Review
- Banner Life Insurance Review
- Brighthouse Financial Review
- Colonial Penn Review
- Foresters Financial Review
- Gerber Grow-Up Plan Review
- Genworth Life Insurance Company Review
- Globe Life Review
- Great American Life Insurance Company Review
- Guardian Life Insurance Review
- John Hancock Life Insurance Review
- Knights of Columbus Life Insurance Review
- Lafayette Life Insurance Review
- Liberty Bankers Life Review
- Lincoln Financial Group Review
- Mass Mutual Review
- MetLife Whole Life Review
- Midland National Review
- Minnesota Life Insurance Company Review
- Mutual of Omaha Life Insurance Review
- Mutual of Omaha Long-Term Care Insurance Review
- Mutual Trust Life Insurance Company Review
- Nassau Re โ Phoenix Life Insurance Company Review
- National Life Group Review
- Nationwide Life Insurance Review
- New York Life Review
- North American Company Review
- Northwestern Mutual Review
- Ohio National Review
- Pacific Life Insurance Company Review
- Penn Mutual Review
- Primerica Life Insurance Review
- Principal Financial Life Insurance Review
- Prosperity Life Review
- Protective Life Insurance Review
- Prudential Life Insurance Review
- Royal Neighbors Review
- Sagicor Life Insurance Company Review
- SBLI Life Insurance Review
- Security Mutual Life Review
- Sentinel Security Life
- State Farm Whole Life Review
- State Life Insurance Company Review
- Symetra Life Insurance Company Review
- Thrivent Life Review
- Transamerica Life Insurance Company Review
- United Home Life Review
- USAA Life Insurance Review
- Voya Life Insurance Company Review
Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Life Insurance Match
When choosing a life insurance company, it’s essential to consider multiple factors, including:
- Financial strength ratings to ensure the company will be around for decades
- Policy types that match your specific needs
- Underwriting criteria that will give you the best possible rates
- Customer satisfaction ratings from current policyholders
- Claims process efficiency for when your beneficiaries need it most
Take the time to research and compare multiple companies before making a decision. Remember, the best life insurance company for someone else might not be the best for your specific situation. By understanding the key factors that differentiate insurance providers and considering your unique needs, you can make an informed choice that provides both financial security and peace of mind.
Working with an independent insurance agent who has access to multiple carriers can also help you navigate the complex world of life insurance and find the policy that best fits your needs and budget.
Ready to Find Your Perfect Policy Match?
Get personalized guidance from an expert who understands your unique situation. Schedule a complimentary consultation with one of our Pro Client Guides today.
No obligation, just expert advice to help you make the best decision for your future.
THE ULTIMATE FREE DOWNLOAD
The Self Banking Blueprint
A Modern Approach To The Infinite Banking Concept
